Holmfirth has Yorkshire’s highest-rated independent coffee shops

Of the 22 towns and cities in the study with 10 or more independent coffee shops, Holmfirth’s independents have the highest average Google rating, ahead of Leeds, Sheffield and York. Halizona compared the ratings of 646 independent coffee shops across 63 Yorkshire towns and cities, as Google showed them on 11 November 2026.
Download the press release and rankings (PDF)Two pages, 43 KB. Free to use with credit to Halizona and a link to this page. See how we measured it.
Key findings
- Holmfirth comes top, averaging 4.82 stars from its 10 qualifying independent coffee shops, and 82% of their 2,580 reviews give five stars.
- Horsforth is second, on 4.78, and Shipley and Leeds share third place on 4.75.
- Leeds is the best-rated city and has the most qualifying independent coffee shops in the study, 51. Sheffield is joint eighth and York sixteenth.
- Halifax, where Halizona is based, is joint tenth with Whitby, on 4.68.
- Independents beat the chains, averaging 4.66 stars against 4.13 for the 231 chain coffee shops. In all 51 towns that have both, the independents’ average is higher than the chains’ combined average.
Where Yorkshire’s coffee towns rank
Every town and city in the study with 10 or more independent coffee shops is ranked here on the average Google rating of those shops. Each coffee shop counted has at least 20 Google reviews. The highest-rated coffee shop shown for each town is its best-rated one with 50 or more reviews. An = sign marks a shared place.
| Rank | Town or city | Independent coffee shops | Average rating | Highest-rated coffee shop (50+ reviews) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | HolmfirthWest Yorkshire | 10 | 4.82 | The Archive Cafe Bistro & Bar4.9 from 436 reviews |
| 2 | HorsforthWest Yorkshire | 12 | 4.78 | Drift5.0 from 55 reviews |
| =3 | ShipleyWest Yorkshire | 17 | 4.75 | gaffé5.0 from 81 reviews |
| =3 | LeedsWest Yorkshire | 51 | 4.75 | 1977 Leeds5.0 from 115 reviews |
| 5 | DoncasterSouth Yorkshire | 24 | 4.74 | Specs Gonzalez Coffee Shop5.0 from 59 reviews |
| 6 | OtleyWest Yorkshire | 11 | 4.73 | River Cafe, Otley5.0 from 82 reviews |
| 7 | BarnsleySouth Yorkshire | 13 | 4.70 | Belle's Coffee Shop and Tea Rooms4.9 from 52 reviews |
| =8 | SheffieldSouth Yorkshire | 46 | 4.69 | 420 Coffee5.0 from 121 reviews |
| =8 | PudseyWest Yorkshire | 10 | 4.69 | Kova Coffee5.0 from 74 reviews |
| =10 | WhitbyNorth Yorkshire | 13 | 4.68 | Lush Coffee4.9 from 540 reviews |
| =10 | HalifaxWest Yorkshire | 20 | 4.68 | Dag&Dem Cafe and Bakery5.0 from 78 reviews |
| 12 | HarrogateNorth Yorkshire | 31 | 4.66 | Heal - Coffee, Lifestyle & Gifting5.0 from 293 reviews |
| 13 | HullEast Yorkshire | 33 | 4.65 | The Blending Room5.0 from 73 reviews |
| =14 | ScarboroughNorth Yorkshire | 23 | 4.63 | Koda Coffee4.9 from 301 reviews |
| =14 | BridlingtonEast Yorkshire | 12 | 4.63 | brew & bake5.0 from 62 reviews |
| 16 | YorkNorth Yorkshire | 37 | 4.62 | Zest Brunch Bar4.9 from 563 reviews |
| 17 | HuddersfieldWest Yorkshire | 22 | 4.59 | Tommy's Lounge5.0 from 77 reviews |
| 18 | Hebden BridgeWest Yorkshire | 10 | 4.56 | Balance Hebden Bridge5.0 from 85 reviews |
| =19 | WakefieldWest Yorkshire | 20 | 4.55 | Nom Bakes & Coffee5.0 from 59 reviews |
| =19 | CastlefordWest Yorkshire | 11 | 4.55 | RECENT Coffee Roasters5.0 from 101 reviews |
| 21 | RotherhamSouth Yorkshire | 17 | 4.51 | Thorpe Coffee + Kitchen4.9 from 81 reviews |
| 22 | BradfordWest Yorkshire | 16 | 4.49 | Café Céline4.7 from 614 reviews |
Holmfirth has 10 qualifying coffee shops, the fewest a town can have and still be ranked, so each one moves its average more than one of Leeds’s 51 would. The 41 towns with fewer than 10 are listed under Towns not ranked.


Independents against the chains
The ranking leaves out chains and supermarket cafes. Counting each branch with 20 or more reviews on its own, Costa’s 91 branches average 4.14, Caffè Nero’s 29 average 4.20 and Starbucks’ 54 average 3.95, against 4.66 for the 646 independents. Town by town, the independents’ average is higher than Costa’s in all 45 towns with a Costa, Caffè Nero’s in all 19 towns with a Nero and Starbucks’ in 29 of the 30 towns with a Starbucks.
Why we did this research
“A lot of business in Yorkshire gets done over a coffee. We meet clients in coffee shops all the time and check the reviews before choosing one. We wanted to see which towns came out best. If you run a coffee shop or any other business, your reviews are your shop window.”
Halizona is a marketing business in Halifax. Helping clients earn and answer their Google reviews is a big part of its work.

Using this research
Please credit Halizona as the source and link to this page, so readers can see the method and the full ranking.
- Download the press release and rankings (PDF)
- The data (CSV): every coffee shop that qualified, with its town, rating, review count and Google place ID, and the 89 coffee shops left out, with the reason.
- Media contact: David Spivey, 01422 771606, info@halizona.com.
Ratings and review counts will drift as new reviews arrive.
How we measured it
- The source. Google Maps, read through the DataForSEO API on 11 November 2026. For each of 63 Yorkshire town and city centres we searched “coffee shop”, “coffee” and “specialty coffee” and kept up to 70 results from each: 189 searches and 5,663 businesses.
- Coffee shops only. A business counts when Google lists its main category as coffee shop, coffee store, coffee roastery, espresso bar or coffee stand, so a cafe-bar that Google files as a coffee shop counts, and a cafe filed as a cafe does not. A coffee shop inside a station, shopping centre or gallery counts like any other.
- What we left out. We left out 89 businesses that Google files as coffee shops and that have 20 or more reviews, each listed in the data with the reason. Of those, 86 are independents with other Google categories naming a different main trade, such as a pub, a shop, a takeaway, a sandwich bar, a dessert parlour, a garden centre or a yoga studio, and no coffee word in their name (coffee, cafe, caffè, espresso, barista, roast, brew, bean, latte, grind, tea room or tea house, with or without accents). The data lists every trade the rule covers. The other three are Merrie England cafes in Huddersfield: LBC and World Coffee Portal reported on 28 July 2026 that the chain had closed all its cafes, but Google still listed them.
- One count per business. The searches overlap, so each business is counted once, for the studied town centre it is nearest to, however far out it is. That means 52 of the 646 independents count for a town their address doesn’t name. The furthest counted is about 8 km from its centre.
- Enough reviews to mean something. A coffee shop needs at least 20 Google reviews. A 5.0 from three reviews is not a measurement.
- Independents. Chains (brands with branches outside Yorkshire, such as Costa, Starbucks and Caffè Nero) and supermarket cafes are left out of the ranking, matched on name, and compared separately above, with each branch that has 20 or more reviews counted on its own. Yorkshire-only groups such as Bettys count as independents.
- The rating. A town’s figure is the plain average of its independent coffee shops’ Google ratings, rounded half up to two decimal places, so 4.675 becomes 4.68. Towns share a place when their rounded averages match.
- Ten or more. A town needs at least 10 qualifying coffee shops to be ranked, whatever its size. With fewer, one shop moves the average too far, so those towns are listed below.
- The highest-rated coffee shop. For each town, its best-rated independent coffee shop with 50 or more reviews whose address is in that town. Ties go to the one with more reviews.
- The September version. This replaces our September 2026 study, which ran one search per town and counted every cafe. This one counts coffee shops only, and three searches per town make the lists more complete.
Towns not ranked
These 41 towns had fewer than 10 qualifying independent coffee shops, so they are in the data but not the ranking: Batley, Beverley, Bingley, Brighouse, Cleckheaton, Cottingham, Dewsbury, Driffield, Elland, Filey, Garforth, Goole, Guiseley, Hessle, Hornsea, Ilkley, Keighley, Knaresborough, Malton, Mexborough, Mirfield, Morley, Normanton, Northallerton, Ossett, Penistone, Pickering, Pocklington, Pontefract, Richmond, Ripon, Selby, Settle, Skipton, Sowerby Bridge, Stocksbridge, Tadcaster, Thirsk, Todmorden, Wath upon Dearne, Wetherby. Ripon, Yorkshire’s smallest city, had six.
About Halizona
Halizona provides outsourced marketing and fractional marketing leadership. Based in Halifax, West Yorkshire, working across Bradford, Huddersfield, Keighley, Skipton, Leeds and nationwide. Halizona brings brand, website, social media and marketing together under one team.
Halizona's promise: we will help the right people find you, trust you, choose you.
Halizona's core values
- We measure what matters to you.
- You’ll always know what we’re doing, why we’re doing it, and what it’s achieving.
- We always and only do the work that makes the biggest difference to your business.
- Founded
- 2018 (company no. 11411758)
- Based in
- Halifax, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom
- Services
- Outsourced marketing, fractional marketing director, marketing strategy, lead generation, brand and identity, web design and development, SEO, GEO and AEO, PPC, social media management, content, photography, video and drone, email marketing, print
- Contact
- 01422 771606, info@halizona.com